In the past, you only really had two choices for a bike – a road bike or a mountain bike, but the introduction of the hybrid bike has changed the landscape somewhat. Fusing the MTB and the road bike brings a new option for cyclists to enjoy.
There are some significant differences between hybrids and mountain bikes, so get geared up as we explore these differences below.
Mountain VS Hybrid – Tires
Starting from the bottom and working our way up, the first noticeable difference is the tires. Mountain bike tires have bigger tires with large tracts of the tread to deliver maximum grip, whether it’s sand, gravel mud, or rock.
By comparison, the hybrid tires are thinner and smoother, designed for road/tar riding surfaces and light off-road riding. Due to the thinner construction, hybrid tires and wheels would not withstand the demanding conditions on proper off-road trails.
Smooth tires provide a much better grip on the road, while they would struggle on rough trails and would be difficult to propel through the mud. While MTBs can be ridden on the street, the ‘knobs’ on their tires wouldn’t be effective on the road and rely more on their low tire pressure and tire compound to deliver grip.
Not only are the tires thinner but slightly smaller than mountain bike tires. As you can see in the table below, hybrid tires and pressures vary from their mountain bike counterparts.
|Bike Type||Tire sizes (inches)||Tire Pressure (psi)|
As you can see from the table, the hybrid is the intermediate between road and mountain bikes, while the tire sizes on road bikes and hybrids are the same, the tire pressures are hugely different.
One of the most significant differences between these two bikes is their suspension systems. Again, based on the type of riding and surfaces, suspension is a critical component.
Mountain bikes require proper suspension to reduce the shock of impact, increasing both their weight and cost, for this reason, most hybrids do not have suspension.
Because hybrids are mostly expected to stay on the road, their wider tires and lower pressures help to absorb small bumps while riding.
Some hybrids have limited front suspension to accommodate some occasional light trail riding. These are limited in their travel, of lower quality, and are not up to mountain bike standards.
Another consideration for suspension is the price. High-quality suspension systems are expensive and drive up the cost of the bike. As a hybrid would mainly be used on the road, the addition of front shocks wouldn’t be necessary.
Also, shocks require some reasonably substantial impact to get them to travel, and it’s unlikely that riding on roads or even train track paths would deliver enough force to activate them.
Mountain bikes have a thick, sturdy frame, which is the heaviest of all the bikes as the primary consideration is strength and not aerodynamics.
Hybrid frames are more like road bike frames with thinner and lighter tubing and more aerodynamically structured to make road riding more efficient while still strong enough to handle some light off-road conditions if required.
Mountain bikes need robust and effective brake systems to allow for proper control of descents over rough terrain. This is why hydraulic disc brake systems with large rotors are usually found on mountain bikes.
While some hybrid bikes do have disc brakes, most have road-bike-style rim brakes that provide effective braking for smooth surface riding.
Rim brakes are also lighter and easier to replace once worn than the mountain bike’s disc brakes. Plus, judging the wear on these is far easier as well.
Weight is an additional consideration, as the lighter the bike is, the easier it is to propel on the road. In contrast, weight is not a consideration on a mountain bike as the stopping power is more important.
Rim brakes also make the Hybrid cost less than the cost of disc brake systems found on its MTB counterpart.
As you can see, the hybrid concept provides a lighter, manageable bike that is cheaper but still allows for some light off-road riding but is mainly aimed at inner-city commuting.
Due to the considerable differences in terrain and elevation, mountain bikes require more gear and gear ratios to allow the rider to maintain cadence while climbing or descending. Having said that, MTB riders don’t usually maintain a single cadence for any significant length of time either.
It wasn’t uncommon to see mountain bikes with double or triple cranksets in the past, but this has evolved to a single crankset configuration except for the cheapest of MTBs.
The modern MTB has a single crankset with a wide-range cassette to give the rider more intuitive gearing and better chain retention. These two factors greatly assist control of the bike as there is NOTHING worse than struggling with gear changes when you need it or having your chain come off while changing gears.
Another element is that a single crankset allows designers to improve structural elements as they don’t have to accommodate two or three front derailleurs.
The MTB cassette has also moved away from the older 8-speed 11-28 tooth cassettes to 10-speed and 12-speed cassettes with toothing from 11-46t on the 10-speed and 10-50t on the 12-speed.
Hybrid bikes typically come with double or triple cranksets similar to road bikes, but there is an increasing trend to spec these with single cranksets as this makes maintenance more straightforward (and cheaper) and offers ease of use as well.
If you’re a beginner or haven’t ridden a bike in a while, the single crankset offers a less intimidating system to get used to and use the gears effectively while depending.
Set up with small enough sprockets to deliver speed and large enough sprockets for climbing, the hybrid provides a good balance between speed and ascension while maintaining good cadence for energy-efficient riding
When it comes to the riding position, hybrid and mountain bikes are very similar, both offering a more upright position that a road bike but not quite like a city bike.
One of the most significant differences between a hybrid and a mountain bike is that these bikes are designed specifically for comfort and ease of use.
When it comes to saddles, the hybrid wins the comfort battle, hands down!
The real beauty of the hybrid is that you don’t need any special gearing or preparations to go for a ride. You can quite happily jump on your bike wearing jeans and flip-flops and ride to work or the shops, herein lies another real bonus- you don’t need a change of clothes every time you want to ride.
Before going on an MTB trail or a long road ride, you need to gear up, which means changing into riding gear and shoes. For example, if you’re going to work, you’d need to pack your working clothes to change into once you arrive.
Versatility, Cargo, and Fenders
As a commuter option, carriers and fenders usually come standard with hybrid bikes. Because many people are looking to use them for work, the pannier and fenders offer an additional value for the hybrid that neither road nor mountain bikes provide.
If you need to carry a backpack with your laptop for work, then slinging it over your back, especially if your commute is a long one, is not comfortable. You end up at work with a stiff and sweaty back from the weight.
Panniers or similar contraptions offer the hybrid rider a way to carry more weight on the bike both to and from work. For example, on a mountain bike, if you needed to pick up groceries on your way home and didn’t have enough space in the backpack to carry them, that would be a tricky ride home.
If you’ve ever tried to ride carrying packages and counterbalance each side to stop you from falling over, you know exactly how difficult this is to do on either a road or mountain bike.
With the cargo carriers on the hybrid, transporting groceries or other small items is a lot easier and safer. So if this sounds like your kind of everyday commute, then the hybrid bike would be the better option.
Speed – Which is Faster?
The answer to this question depends totally on where you are going to ride. On the road, the hybrid will be faster as the heavier mountain bike will require more effort to propel it and the ‘knobbly’ tires aren’t as efficient on the road as the smoother tires of the hybrid.
The lighter and more aerodynamic frame will also make the hybrid faster on the road, and some combinations come with a more ‘dropped’ handlebar position giving you the option to be lower as if on a road bike.
If you’re talking about the trail and proper off-road, the mountain bike will be faster!
Where Does The Hybrid Win Out?
The hybrid will not be the best choice if you plan long road rides or much tougher off-road trail experiences. While you could certainly do some long miles on the hybrid, and it would perform successfully, you aren’t going to see anyone win the Tour De France on a hybrid anytime soon!
The same applies to heavy trail riding. The lighter frame won’t take the punishment meted out on the actual MTB-style trails, and you risk both damage to the bike and injury to yourself doing so. For some light off the road, the hybrid would again be competent but not exceptional.
From a fitness perspective, they also offer a good option, especially if you have an old riding injury that precludes the use of a road or mountain bike. You can do cardio and conditioning by varying your riding conditions between road and sand/ gravel surfaces.
Overall, the lower cost of both the bike and the gear, the comfort, and the convenience make the hybrid the ideal bike for urban commuting. While you could use a mountain bike for commuting, the hybrid would be a better performer.
In short, if you are looking for a bike that provides good value overall in terms of cost, low maintenance, riding versatility, and sheer pleasure, the hybrid ticks all of those boxes. Moving to a future where many US and European cities are offering more designated bike lanes, it’s easy to see why the hybrid may well become the bike of choice for the city.
- Mountain bike vs. road bike
- Mountain bike vs. cruiser bike
- Mountain bike vs. gravel bike
- Mountain bike vs. fat bike
I started mountain biking many years ago to improve my overall health state. After my first ride, I fell in love with the sport. Now I spend dozens of hours a week researching and training to compete in local XC and Enduro events.