Mountain Bike Vs. Fat Bike (Explained for Beginners)

Fat bikes are bicycles with wide tires, sometimes twice the width of the tires on a typical mountain bike. The wide tires usually are underinflated, making them ideal for riding over soft surfaces like snow, sand, and mud. With recent advances in technology, these bikes can be taken onto more technical terrain.

Core differences between a typical mountain bike and a fat bike are tire width and handling. Mountain bikes require specialized equipment to make the most of varied off-road terrain, fat bikes rely on tire width and low wheel pressure to roll over snow, sand, and other soft terrains.

Although fat bikes are often classified as mountain bikes, they occupy a unique space in the market. Previously, fat bikes were popular only on snow and sandy terrain; now, we see them in other areas of mountain biking territory. While parallels can be drawn between the bikes, each nevertheless fulfills a different purpose for the rider.

What Is A Mountain Bike

Mountain bikes are manufactured to be more durable than other types of bikes. Stresses from variable terrain can take their toll on components and frames alike. 

Strong wheels, knobby tires, adjustable suspension, sturdy frames, powerful brakes, and a straight handlebar are some elements that facilitate durability.

What Is A Fat Bike?

Fat bikes combine the look and frame of a mountain bike with fat tires up to 5″ in width. 

Even if the frame is similar to a mountain bike, there are significant differences:

• Rigid frame, mostly without suspension
• The complete bike is heavy compared to other mountain bikes.
• Gear ratios are for powering the bike along; speed depends on how strong the rider is
• Fat tires act as a suspension system.  

Tire pressure is much lower than on mountain bikes, which results in fantastic traction, They are stable but lack in the speed department.

Differences Between Mountain Bikes and Fat Bikes

A comprehensive, but not definitive list comparing the two bikes really brings the differences home. 

Nr.	Mountain bike	Fat bike
1	Range of differently priced bikes.	Significant investment as a beginner bike, you pay for the versatility
2	Bikes can be very light.	Heavyweight bikes, although technological advances are shaving off some weight.
3	Harder tires (more pressure) are easier to maneuver over most terrain, also roads.	Softer tires make them challenging to ride, particularly on the road.
4	Gearing is optimized for the type of riding (more gears)	Intense workout, even over short distances
5	Suitable for difficult terrain as it’s nimble and quick to respond, but not as comfortable	Lots of cushioning, traction, and comfort. Good for difficult terrain
6	Multi-functional – can cope with a wide variety of terrain.	Multi-function bike – can cope with most terrain.
7	Can’t handle all-terrain, esp heavy mud, sand, and snow.	Fantastic traction: Handle on and off-road trips and terrain that’s soft sand, snow, and ice, as well as deep mud
8	Not suited to ride deep sand and mud	Ride terrain not usually able to on a mountain bike
9	Can’t ride in snowy areas in winter as they sink into the soft snow	Ride in diverse weather conditions
10	Harsher ride as the tires are not run soft. Front and rear suspension systems do mitigate.	Smooth and comfortable ride
11	Less traction and grip as the tire is narrower and pumped harder.	Excellent traction /grip
12	Wheel damage is common as they are larger, narrower, and structurally weaker than fat bike rims.	Fewer broken spokes and cracked rims as the tire absorbs impact
13	Replacement parts are easier to find.	Replacement parts can be difficult to find because they aren’t so popular.
14	More efficient ride: The narrower tires with higher pressure decrease rolling resistance	Inefficient to ride due to the high rolling resistance
15	Lighter and faster	Heavy and slower
16	More maneuverable	Less maneuverable
17	Many frame options because they are the most popular types of bikes	Frame options limited
18	Can swap tires out and put road-ready wheels on.	Tire options limited
19	Discomfort can usually be corrected by a good bike fit	Can cause knee and hip pain due to wide Q-Factor
20	Builds technical skills as it doesn’t just plow over obstacles.	Doesn’t teach technical skills as it rolls over most obstacles with incredible ease
21	Tire pressure is just checked before a ride.	Best to adjust tire pressure over the varied terrain in a ride to increase riding efficiency

Best Terrain for Mountain Bike VS. Fat Bike

Mountain bikes are versatile and conquer just about any terrain, from flat, fast sections to technical rough hilly terrain.  Suspension systems make the ride as smooth and comfortable as possible.

Fat bikes provide grip and unrivaled traction because the tire’s width is spreading bike and rider weight across a greater area. The increased contact area makes it possible to get through otherwise troublesome snow, mud, soft sand, and the like. 

Fat tires are less likely to slip on wet ground, cut into deep sand, or crack when in contact with icy corners. The tire acts as a suspension system. 

It comes into its own on snow paths and sandy beaches; typical mountain bikes cannot ride. For trails where fast reaction times and nimble steering and movement are required, a mountain bike will be more successful.

Ride in any weather

For riders who are of the viewpoint that lousy weather doesn’t exist, only inappropriate gear, the good news is that fat bikes adjust to just about any weather conditions.

Due to the extra grip the wide tires provide, no surface will be a match for the wheels. They will grip wet stone or tarmac. Neither will they cut and dig in mud or snow.  Most fat bike tires come in a tread designed for off-road terrain, but some are available in an extra knobby pattern suitable for snow.

And, if you really need a reason to ride in truly windy conditions, here is the last thought:  Since fat bikes weigh more than regular mountain bikes, fat bikes are safer to ride in strong winds than their lighter counterparts.

A Comfortable Ride – Saddle Choice

Riding any bike is usually not the most comfortable activity as the seat and handlebar are the only points supporting most of the rider’s weight. Comfort depends on saddle type, position on the bike, and suspension system.

Fat bike saddles are loosely modeled on the mountain bike saddle, which has some padding. Mountain bike saddles are constantly evolving to keep up with the latest frame geometry.

As mountain bike frame designs keep stretching the distance between the bottom bracket and bars for increased stability, the steeper the seat post angles become. That means saddle length becomes shorter and in some cases, the back cut out in the saddle is no longer necessary.

The choice of fat bike saddles comes down to the type of riding primarily engaged in. If you constantly push the pace and look for a hard workout, a performance saddle could be the more comfortable version.

If it’s more about having the most comfortable ride, a cushioned saddle is the way to go. It doesn’t mean that you can’t push the pace with this kind of saddle. Constant chafing of the saddle is an indication to consider a move to a more performance-based model.

Bike maintenance

Mountain bikes are complicated machines with many moving parts which require maintenance regularly. Routinely cleaning the bike and exposed parts after every ride will increase longevity.

Having the suspension systems serviced at correct intervals is essential if your riding performance should remain the same.

Cleaning off dirt and grime from wet and snowy rides after every ride is a must to minimize corrosion from sand, salt and snow deposits.

Considering fat bikes are mostly of rigid frame build, there are not as many moving parts that require routine servicing or get damaged and need to be replaced regularly.

Riding Gear

The mountain biking gear needed is relatively terrain-specific. Cross-country riders will have a good helmet and gloves, while downhill riders will wear full-face helmets, goggles, and protective elbow and knee guards. Appropriate weather-related gear like rain jackets or windjammers are readily available

Fat bike riders spend a lot of time outdoors in winter.  The gear required in snow-bound areas is the same as for snowboarding or skiing.

Keep the head, hands, and feet warm. Layer clothes, wear two layers of gloves, fit booties overshoes or ride in winter MTB shoes and flat pedals. Wear a ski mask under your helmet or wear a ski helmet in exceedingly cold conditions.

Conclusion

Mountain biking is a sport that requires specialized equipment to handle the demands of off-road trails. It’s about exploring, experiencing nature, and testing your limits both mentally and physically.

Fat bikes were initially developed to be sand and snow bikes, the main difference between fat bikes and regular mountain bikes is that fat tires are wider than standard tires, making them more suitable for riding on soft surfaces like sand, mud, or snow and hard ice-covered areas.

The unusual proportions of fat bikes draw attention. But actually riding such a bike is the only way to understand why anyone who has ridden one enjoyed it.

Related articles:

• Mountain bike vs. hybrid bike
• Mountain bike vs. cruiser bike
• Mountain bike vs. gravel bike
• Mountain bike vs. road bike